By Malcolm Cook, Yash Shukla, Rajan Rawal, Dennis Loveday, Luciano Caruggi de Faria and Charalampos Angelopoulos. 2020, Published by Centre for Advanced Research in Building Science and Energy, CEPT University, ISBN: 9781838031008.
Peter Graham (Global
Buildings Performance Network) explains how this new design guide can make a large
contribution to mitigating climate change and reduce electricity demand. Good
design and adaptive behaviours can significantly reduce dependency on air
conditioning in India’s new apartment buildings.
Despite our best efforts at improving building energy
efficiency, total energy demand and associated emissions continues to grow. The
buildings sector’s global energy-related emissions have risen 7% since 2010 (Global
Alliance on Buildings and Construction et al., 2019), driven by urbanisation,
new construction, increasing demand for electricity and inefficient cooling
(International Energy Agency, 2017). The GHG emissions curve in the buildings
sector continues upward.
To meet the GHG reductions recommended by the IPCC (2018), global building sector emissions must reduce by 8% per year and current rates of energy efficiency improvements must double. India is projected to have the largest growth in new construction globally after 2030 adding more than 25 billion m2 of floor area (GABC et al., 2019), and the second largest growth in cooling energy demand between now and 2050. Reducing the growth in the energy demand of India’s building sector is therefore globally significant, offering more than 8% of global building energy-related greenhouse gas (GHG) mitigation potential (Ürge-Vorstaz et al, 2012). About 90% of this mitigation potential is related to achieving energy savings in new buildings (Diddi, 2017).
About 70% of the growth in building energy demand in India is driven by the residential sector. Unchecked, it is possible that Indian residences could drive an eight- fold increase in residential building energy demand by 2030. Ensuring new residential construction is as energy efficient as possible could reduce increased demand for energy 5-fold (Rawal & Shukla, 2014). Achieving this outcome requires a reduction in the dependency on air conditioning to provide thermal comfort.
Air conditioning provides a crutch for poor climatic design and makes living in dense, homogenous high-rise buildings possible if there is a reliable electricity supply. However, increased electricity demand due to home air conditioners has outpaced electricity supply in many countries, leading to greater peak electricity demand in hot weather and increased risk of power supply interruptions. Climate change is increasing the frequency and duration of heatwaves, further increasing the vulnerability of power supply. In turn, this creates a human vulnerability if buildings cannot provide thermal adequacy without air conditioning.
A fundamental solution is designing apartments to enable
people to maintain their thermal adequacy by adapting their behaviour and
surroundings to changes in their local climate. Inexpensive technologies e.g.
operable windows, external shading, and ceiling fans can be combined with
insulative materials and climatically sensitive floor planning and façade
design to minimise the need for air conditioning. Good design therefore
provides building occupants with a choice of thermal comfort strategies, and
therefore a diversity of options for reducing electricity use and saving money.
A new Design Guide to Low Energy
Cooling and Ventilation for Indian Residences (LECaVIR) (Cook et al.,
2020) is therefore to be applauded. Developed jointly by Loughborough
University in the UK and CEPT University’s Centre for Advanced Research in
Building Science and Energy in Ahmedabad, India, this design guide shows that
many of the measures that provide thermal comfort in buildings need not require
electricity at all. As the authors point out “… our basic need for thermal comfort indoors is a main driver of
building energy demand world-wide.” A key aim of building designers should
therefore be to “…deliver thermal comfort
to occupants as energy efficiently as possible”. The key to achieving this
aim is providing people with choice and agency in adapting their immediate
surroundings to maintain their thermal comfort.
The LECaVIR Guide provides useful step-by-step design
processes for providing natural and mixed-mode ventilation and cooling in
Indian apartment buildings. Following these steps leads to a greater
understanding of the fundamental principles of climatic design, thermal
comfort, and vernacular cooling strategies. It also simplifies and translates
the complex dynamic modelling of adaptive comfort into simple diagrams, and
draws on research into adaptive behaviours and clothing that influence people’s
perceived thermal comfort in an Indian cultural context.
The guide is for architects, engineers, building
operators, students and builders. However, it will also prove empowering for
purchasers and investors who will be able to ‘read’ an apartment design to
determine its likely adaptive thermal capacity, and therefore their ability to maintain
comfort and reduce electricity bills.
It will also contribute to the Global Building Performance Network (GBPN) program being implemented by CEPT and the Alliance for an Energy Efficiency Economy (AEEE) to support affordable housing developers and local governments in implementing the Energy Conservation Building Code for Residences (ECBC-R). The ECBC-R was launched in December 2018 and will take time to be fully adopted by Indian States and to be effectively implemented in building projects. The power of a well-written design guide is that it can be applied immediately. When aligned with policy goals, design guides can extend regulatory and voluntary performance standards, and contribute to capacity building in local markets.
In the first months of this year, the world has been overrun by the COVID-19 pandemic. The most effective public health strategy for slowing the spread of the virus and saving lives has been to restrict travel, close venues where crowds can gather, and stay at home. The importance of having safe, healthy shelter has become critically obvious to all of us. Yet the survival strategies of staying and working from home, schooling our children online, even washing hands and maintaining a safe ‘social distance’ rely on the commodities and qualities of space and infrastructure that are accessible only by the most privileged. People in many parts of the world are disadvantaged by lack of access to electricity supply.
The unprecedented scale of the current ‘lock-down’ has also brought the construction industry to a standstill. The drivers of buildings sector emissions growth – new construction, increasing household income, demand for electricity are momentarily suppressed. This pause in construction activity gives the supply side (developers, practitioners, builders, estate agents, etc) a once-in-a generation opportunity to ensure our social and economic recovery is aligned with the necessity of reducing GHG emissions and energy demand while protecting the health and well-being of us all. It is a unique opportunity to gather and consolidate our knowledge and skills (based on tools, guidelines and training) to change our practices. Guides such as the LECaVIR make an important contribution by showing in practical terms how good climatic design affords comfort in the home as a right rather than as a privilege.
References
Cook, M., Shulka,
Y., Rawal, R., Loveday, D., de Faria, L., Angelopoulos, C. (2020). Low
Energy Cooling and Ventilation in Indian Residences Design Guide. CEPT
Research & Development Foundation & Loughborough University. http://carbse.org/reports-and-articles/
Diddi, S. (2017). Scenarios of energy conservation building code (ECBC) in India. Bureau of Energy Efficiency Presentation. Powerpoint presentation. Retrieved from http://ace-e2.eu/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/S1-P1_Saurabh_Scenario-of-ECBC-in-India.pdf
Global Alliance for Buildings and Construction, International Energy Agency and the United Nations Environment Programme. (2019). 2019 Global Status Report for Buildings and Construction: Towards a Zero-emission, Efficient and Resilient Buildings and Construction Sector. Paris: UNEP. https://globalabc.org/sites/default/files/2020-03/GSR2019.pdf
International
Energy Agency. (2017).Energy Technology Perspectives http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/energy_tech-2017-en
IPCC. (2018). Global Warming of 1.5°C. An IPCC Special Report on the impacts of global warming of 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels and related global greenhouse gas emission pathways, in the context of strengthening the global response to the threat of climate change, sustainable development, and efforts to eradicate poverty. [V. Masson-Delmotte, P. Zhai, H.-O. Pörtner, D. Roberts, J. Skea, P.R. Shukla, A. Pirani, W. Moufouma-Okia, C. Péan, R. Pidcock, S. Connors, J.B.R. Matthews, Y. Chen, X. Zhou, M.I. Gomis, E. Lonnoy, T. Maycock, M. Tignor, and T. Waterfield (eds.)]. Geneva: Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/
Rawal, R. & Shukla, Y. (2014) Residential Buildings in India: Energy Use Projections and Savings. Paris: Global Building Performance Network. https://www.gbpn.org/reports/residential-buildings-india-energy-use-projections-and-savings-potentials-0
Ürge-Vorsatz, D., Petrichenko, K., Antal, M., Staniec, M., Labelle,M., Ozden, E., Labzin, E. (2012). Best Practice Policies for Low Energy and Carbon Buildings. A Scenario Analysis. Research report prepared by the Center for Climate Change and Sustainable Policy (3CSEP) for the Global Buildings Performance Network. https://www.gbpn.org/reports/best-practice-policies-low-carbon-energy-buildings-based-scenario-analysis
Spatiotemporal evaluation of embodied carbon in urban residential development
I Talvitie, A Amiri & S Junnila
Energy sufficiency in buildings and cities: current research, future directions [editorial]
M Sahakian, T Fawcett & S Darby
Sufficiency, consumption patterns and limits: a survey of French households
J Bouillet & C Grandclément
Health inequalities and indoor environments: research challenges and priorities [editorial]
M Ucci & A Mavrogianni
Operationalising energy sufficiency for low-carbon built environments in urbanising India
A B Lall & G Sethi
Promoting practices of sufficiency: reprogramming resource-intensive material arrangements
T H Christensen, L K Aagaard, A K Juvik, C Samson & K Gram-Hanssen
Culture change in the UK construction industry: an anthropological perspective
I Tellam
Are people willing to share living space? Household preferences in Finland
E Ruokamo, E Kylkilahti, M Lettenmeier & A Toppinen
Towards urban LCA: examining densification alternatives for a residential neighbourhood
M Moisio, E Salmio, T Kaasalainen, S Huuhka, A Räsänen, J Lahdensivu, M Leppänen & P Kuula
A population-level framework to estimate unequal exposure to indoor heat and air pollution
R Cole, C H Simpson, L Ferguson, P Symonds, J Taylor, C Heaviside, P Murage, H L Macintyre, S Hajat, A Mavrogianni & M Davies
Finnish glazed balconies: residents’ experience, wellbeing and use
L Jegard, R Castaño-Rosa, S Kilpeläinen & S Pelsmakers
Modelling Nigerian residential dwellings: bottom-up approach and scenario analysis
C C Nwagwu, S Akin & E G Hertwich
Mapping municipal land policies: applications of flexible zoning for densification
V Götze, J-D Gerber & M Jehling
Energy sufficiency and recognition justice: a study of household consumption
A Guilbert
Linking housing, socio-demographic, environmental and mental health data at scale
P Symonds, C H Simpson, G Petrou, L Ferguson, A Mavrogianni & M Davies
Measuring health inequities due to housing characteristics
K Govertsen & M Kane
Provide or prevent? Exploring sufficiency imaginaries within Danish systems of provision
L K Aagaard & T H Christensen
Imagining sufficiency through collective changes as satisfiers
O Moynat & M Sahakian
US urban land-use reform: a strategy for energy sufficiency
Z M Subin, J Lombardi, R Muralidharan, J Korn, J Malik, T Pullen, M Wei & T Hong
Mapping supply chains for energy retrofit
F Wade & Y Han
Operationalising building-related energy sufficiency measures in SMEs
I Fouiteh, J D Cabrera Santelices, A Susini & M K Patel
Promoting neighbourhood sharing: infrastructures of convenience and community
A Huber, H Heinrichs & M Jaeger-Erben
New insights into thermal comfort sufficiency in dwellings
G van Moeseke, D de Grave, A Anciaux, J Sobczak & G Wallenborn
‘Rightsize’: a housing design game for spatial and energy sufficiency
P Graham, P Nourian, E Warwick & M Gath-Morad
Implementing housing policies for a sufficient lifestyle
M Bagheri, L Roth, L Siebke, C Rohde & H-J Linke
The jobs of climate adaptation
T Denham, L Rickards & O Ajulo
Structural barriers to sufficiency: the contribution of research on elites
M Koch, K Emilsson, J Lee & H Johansson
Life-cycle GHG emissions of standard houses in Thailand
B Viriyaroj, M Kuittinen & S H Gheewala
IAQ and environmental health literacy: lived experiences of vulnerable people
C Smith, A Drinkwater, M Modlich, D van der Horst & R Doherty
Living smaller: acceptance, effects and structural factors in the EU
M Lehner, J L Richter, H Kreinin, P Mamut, E Vadovics, J Henman, O Mont & D Fuchs
Disrupting the imaginaries of urban action to deliver just adaptation [editorial]
V Castán-Broto, M Olazabal & G Ziervogel
Building energy use in COVID-19 lockdowns: did much change?
F Hollick, D Humphrey, T Oreszczyn, C Elwell & G Huebner
Evaluating past and future building operational emissions: improved method
S Huuhka, M Moisio & M Arnould
Normative future visioning: a critical pedagogy for transformative adaptation
T Comelli, M Pelling, M Hope, J Ensor, M E Filippi, E Y Menteşe & J McCloskey
Nature for resilience reconfigured: global- to-local translation of frames in Africa
K Rochell, H Bulkeley & H Runhaar
How hegemonic discourses of sustainability influence urban climate action
V Castán Broto, L Westman & P Huang
Fabric first: is it still the right approach?
N Eyre, T Fawcett, M Topouzi, G Killip, T Oreszczyn, K Jenkinson & J Rosenow
Social value of the built environment [editorial]
F Samuel & K Watson
Understanding demolition [editorial]
S Huuhka
Data politics in the built environment [editorial]
A Karvonen & T Hargreaves
Latest Commentaries
Systems Thinking is Needed to Achieve Sustainable Cities
As city populations grow, a critical current and future challenge for urban researchers is to provide compelling evidence of the medium and long-term co-benefits of quality, low-carbon affordable housing and compact urban design. Philippa Howden-Chapman (University of Otago) and Ralph Chapman (Victoria University of Wellington) explain why systems-based, transition-oriented research on housing and associated systemic benefits is needed now more than ever.
Unmaking Cities Can Catalyse Sustainable Transformations
Andrew Karvonen (Lund University) explains why innovation has limitations for achieving systemic change. What is also needed is a process of unmaking (i.e. phasing out existing harmful technologies, processes and practices) whilst ensuring inequalities, vulnerabilities and economic hazards are avoided. Researchers have an important role to identify what needs dismantling, identify advantageous and negative impacts and work with stakeholders and local governments.